New York Giants

Is football worth the risk?

Since the days of leather helmets, football has been one of America’s most vigorous, violent and beloved past times. There’s a hidden cost however to playing the game, and concerns of long-term brain injuries are growing.  It’s leading some former players like Harry Carson to become an outspoken advocate, raising awareness of the unintended consequences of playing professional football. As good as it sounds you can’t just keep your heart in the game and your head out.

Harry Carson played with the New York Giants as their linebacker for thirteen years, from 1976-1988. It wasn’t until years after the 231st member of the Pro Football Hall of Fame retired that he realized he suffered from Post Concussion Syndrome (“PCS”), a disease that he will have for the rest of his life. Carson believes he suffered from 12-18 concussions as a player. There is a very long list of former players who suffer/suffered from PCS or Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (“CTE”).  These disorders are linked to dementia, erratic behavior, short-term memory loss, anxiety, dizziness, severe depression.  There is also some evidence that PCS and CTE  may lead to suicidal behavior.

Harry has served as an advisor to the Congress of Neurological Surgeons and is a member of the Brain Injury Association’s Sports Injury Prevention Council. Carson has also been a very strong advocate for the plight of his National Football League brethren.  He personally lobbied commissioner Roger Goodell for enhanced benefits and disability coverage for retired players. At 57, Harry is the author of the poignant book “Captain For Life” (published last August). He covers his own cognitive problems and suicidal thoughts that he believes were brought on by football. He tries to tell players to listen to the facts now, not to wait until it affects them. Something he himself did, stating, “We listened, but did not hear or process it”. He wants every parent to be fully informed that his or her child could sustain neurological damage. A study showed that kids who play football will receive 8,000 head impacts by the time they graduate college.

Being an avid football fan I do not want to lose the sport I invest so much of mine in to. But I do feel that many changes should be made, not just moving kickoffs forward 5 yards. There may not be a concussion proof helmet out there, but there are some penalties that go beyond fines and suspensions that can be instituted for repeat offenders like Steelers James Harrison and Lions Ndamukong Suh who seem to think they can’t change their style of play. Kick them out of the league, set an example. I know head injuries happen all the time are not always the result of illegal contact, but this could help. Yes, that might mean getting rid of some great players, but why should we lose football because of athletes who think of only themselves.

Powered By DT Author Box

Written by Wendy

Wendy

One could say sports has been instilled upon me since birth, being born on a Superbowl Sunday in 1979. From day one I was bleeding Giants blue. My father brought me up to become a women writer and broadcaster for men professional sports. Women seldom did such a thing, and he wanted me to be one of the few. The New York Football Giants was a religion in my home, so much so that we had to pray to a Giants plaque before every game. Die hard enough to the extent of having the Giants helmet tattooed to back of my neck with the Superbowl wins written on the sides of it. Growing up with an older brother, he and his friends let me play street football, baseball, and basketball with them. I’ve done internships with News 12 sports New York, ABC sports New York, 1050 AM ESPN New York, and while attending Queens College hosted the football radio show.

5 comments on “Is football worth the risk?

  1. Great article cuz, difficult subject but clearly the NFL needs to do more for the disabled retirees.

  2. Great article on a topic that should be getting more headlines! Injuries will always occur but hopefully the NFL can take steps to mitigate these type of injuries that have long term effects on players, even when they are done playing.

  3. Im my opinion, the guys who play the game today accepts 10 mil a year to get hit in the head and they know its coming. Its their decision to play so I can’t feel sorry for them. As for Carson, or anybody else for that matter: 250 lb guys running full speed into each other is not good thing, never was and never will be. And if they don’t know that or know that there will be consequences…seems that there is aleeady something wrong with their heads! Play ball or go find a desk job. These guys are modern day gladiators. The roman gladiators knew death was an option.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Protected with IP Blacklist CloudIP Blacklist Cloud